I don't inherently hate the stuff, and there's some legitimately good ones out there (Akira immediately comes to mind), but the vast majority that I've been exposed to are hamfisted trope parades of cliched schlock and twists that are either predictable, insanely implausible, or straight up lazy writing (Season 1 end of Code Geass which was thrust upon me by a couple of friends at the time), such that it makes me reflexively cringe.
Also using animu images is one thing; employing shitty animu tropes is obviously entirely another. I suppose if it takes on a satirical bent as most things do in PirateZ though, it's not so bad.