Scrollbar

[Volutar]

What scrollbar design would be looking better?

[Volutar]

Next portion

[hsbckb]

I vote for the first one but using the colour of the letter i.e. lighter

[Volutar]

I vote for the first one but using the colour of the letter i.e. lighter

Lighter colors would obstruct view and distract. It's shouldn't be "screaming" anyhow. That's the point.

[Yankes]

I would go for last one.

[kkmic]

The first one is the "natural" look everyone expects, but It is indeed too heavy.

I would go with the last one too, but I have a question first: Would you be able to click and drag the position indicator? Or it will be just that  - an indicator - and to scroll the information you will have to click the arrows?

[Volutar]

kkmic, ideally it would be draggable, but firstly as indicator. At least

[luke83]

1

[Korenn]

first!

I mean, I vote for the first one   

[Volutar]

Just for notice. Those are 1 and 6. If scrollbar frame fills almost whole scrollbar in 1 it will look too occlusive, while in 6 it will be hollow.

[moriarty]

my vote is for #1 or #5.

if we go with #1, though, I too think that it is too heavy/obstructing. perhaps make it less wide? if you take two pixels off each side, so that it fits between the vertical lines, would that still look good?

[Volutar]

It will be harder to aim when dragging will be enabled.
Two pixels from each side is 4 pixels, overall width of it is 15, so it's 1/3 of width. So besides of being heavy, it also become less "elegant" because of non regular width.

[xracer]

I prefer the latter with the hollow center i think it looks light weight,

From the original lost that will be number 2

[kkmic]

If scrollbar frame fills almost whole scrollbar in 1 it will look too occlusive, while in 6 it will be hollow.

Yup, #6 is better.

You should open a poll

[Volutar]

i don't know how to make polls!